Identity wars are useful when politicians wish to deepen or to widen their power over the populace. Such wars divide populations into smaller groups, which can then be pitted against one another. While each group is focusing on its own challenges and fighting other groups to defend its limited interests, all groups are ignoring the big picture. They are missing opportunities. They are ignoring their real manipulator. They have been divided and conquered.
So, we the people, divided and conquered, focus on a myriad of wars: class, race, gender, disabilities, environmental, social justice, gentrification, fetus-as-person, open space, climate change, drug, opiod. Meanwhile, our liberties are decimated unnoticed. We are slaves to the IRS, mandated to pay our pound of flesh under dire penalties if we do not obey. We are hostages to the obscene costs of healthcare and education. We are automatic criminals given the numerous laws and regulations at every level of government, of which we are bound to break some unwittingly. Our Bill of Rights is constantly under siege.
Some enclaves in these United States have become epicenters of identity wars. California is such an epicenter. The state’s residents never tire of group warfare, while they lose their basic constitutional liberties, such as free speech, self defense against tyranny, or local jurisdictional control of their destiny. At present California is fighting the “housing crisis,” pitting NIMBYs vs. YIMBYs, while politicians crank out laws obliterating local control of what gets built where and how.
As Joseph-Marie, Comte de Maistre, 19th century lawyer, diplomat, writer, and philosopher said every nation has the government it deserves. In a republic such as the United States, where the ballot box is available to all citizens, this maxim could be interpreted as meaning every individual has the government he/she deserves.